how long wait for viagra work over counter viagra alternative viagra alternative usa quick does maxalt work viagra tablets for sale uk doxycycline acne how long to work cialis cures how to prevent stuffy nose with viagra test viagra cobra120 breakable cialis tablets how quickly is fluconazole out of your system small sildenafil buy cialis within usa best place to buy cialis in tequan mexico generic zocor vs lipitor tadalafil and pulmonary hypertension buy lexapro online without can i buy lamisil spray in thailand cialis efeitos colaterais cheap viagra spain tablet tadalafil female viagra srpay viagra blue pill gnp how long does erection from viagra last i wanna buy viagra in sydney can u buy cialis at walmart plant viagra flower does 5mg propecia work singulair time to work how many diflucan does it take to kill ringworm viagra vliegen celerity stand herbal viagra buy cialis uae can viagra be taken by smokers zyprexa sleeping pill what are nursing implication for gabapentin viagra in malaysia without prescription fluconazole 150 mg en london canada to buy is buying cialis safe from the internet free samples by mail cialis can i dissolve regulat cialis under my tingue 1 adipex diet pill what is better levitra or cialis how can i buy a single viagra pills more than one erection from cialis canada drug online viagra indiana viagra is internet viagra any good viagra generic vs brand name cialis once a day pricing viagra filma viagra split prodaja how many months of propecia buspar type of drug viagra and venous leak cheap diet pills with ephedra what if i take two 5mg of cialis at the same time cymbalta has stopped working levitra and young men ways to make viagra absorb faster montelukast toddlers sodium generic freely available viagras in bangalore generic lexapro and muscle. aches whatare levitra tablets buy cialis online in usa buy gabapentin using paypal account will viagra help my nerves amoxicillin need prescription singapore kamagra didnt work release diet pill gnc where do i get a sample pack of cialis why is the price of cialis going up show viagra hard dick metronidazole side effects pill cialis to china low cost viagra india wet viagra fuck marcoumar en tadalafil what is an honest site to buy viagra buy lasix steroids viagra red information buy amoxicillin online europe how often we should use cialis roy d. mercer viagra dog generic bactrim cost at walgreens is cialis prescription only in canada viagra oder cialis bsf viagra epinephrine viagra fast delivery polska warszawa demographic information using viagra in india levitra shortness of breath use of viagra first time medicial uses for cialis importance of generic viagra bactrim cialis contraindication took viagra then smoked weed cdc doxycycline dose vardenafil in the uae how much is levitra without insurance viagra citalopram where can you get viagra buying copy cialis on street is it safe buy viagra in pharmacy in mumbai taking two 100 viagra viagra gmail cost for zovirax 400 mg tablet in uk senior discount viagra hoodia diet pill diet hoodia cactus diet pill review are vasodialators like viagra viagra for fertility treatments why does levitra say bayer on it where can i buy zithromax if women had viagra walmart price for generic lipitor where to buy azithromycin 1 gm pwd packet how long before seroquel xr works buy viagra user doxycycline walmart cost erectile function and cialis it got bigger cialis best web site to get viagra reviewed what are the side effects of using viagra to escorts cialis prevent premature buy cialis line com cymgen generic cymbalta will viagra erection last after how to avoid weight gain on paxil price of avodart generic escitalopram and hives. lexapro generic how long do erections with one dose of viagra propecia monthly cost closest thing to viagra cost of lamisil canada ship levitra how much is cialis in toronto while taking cialis when do i orgasm how long till cialis 5mg kicks in where can i get viagra in toronto quickly best diet diet loss loss pill weight weight why does it take so long for cialis to work cialis strength vs viagra strength viagra live quetiapine how to use levitra greenland sildenafil merck cialis 10 mg tablet albuterol what does it do symptoms of generic lipitor recall metformin side effects overdose took too many viagra viagra vs amlodipine besylate levitra da 5 mg costo viagra side effects nasal doxycycline tablets what are they for cialis prodaja u bih cialis one per day builds up in the body what happens to a lady if she eats viagra viagra after ejacularion can levitra have different colors cialis delivered to norway laws on viagra till what age finasteride uk cialis black is 2 cialis better than one viagra order china small sildenafil if wellbutrin not working morroco viagra female cialis au no prescription lexapro online problems generic nexium where can i purchase nolvadex filme da maria helena e o viagra viagra government funding viagra pills generics buy lamisil pills flagyl susp for cats what is it cialis two days in a row viagra from mumbai is it safe plavix buy london what are the disadvantages of viagra paroxetine hcl doses cialis tips on use discount tadalafil generic propecia generic available rxcialislowprice shop levitra orodispersible cialis commercial lady with shoe meijer cialis prices how to recognize real viagra vardenafil generic .au how big can your dick get from viagra levofloxacin dose in neonates ejaculationviagra cialis prescription cost at walmart viagra patent experation date good does valacyclovir work 40 mg dose of levitra patent on viagra viagra helpt bij ms levitra generic cialis viagra levitra 10 mg filmtabletten ihre wirkung can viagra make an erection harder were to get viagra in perth appress diet pills reviews how long does viagra take to come out of your body cost of viagra at pharmacy cialis loss sensation peter dunn viagra online pharmacy usa no prescription doxycycline 100mg howcan you make viagra work better where to buy acyclovir in singapore viagra extend where can i order viagra vardenafil india brands is 15 mg cialis enough does cialis create a smell in the mouth purchasing viagra in tijuana mexico what is the mean of viagra in urdu pros and cons of daily cialis blood pressure medications can i use cialis levitra 10mg no prescription cialis user reviews uk is cialis a anti depression medicine levitra buy in uk online does levitra have long term effects 40 g cialis uk how to mix viagra with drink where to buy albuterol liquid bodybuilding forum tadalafil muscle pain what dosage of flagyl is used to treat uti what to expect propecia levitra anytime scrub hat viagra azithromycin 1 gm without prescription how reverse propecia side effects cialis dose bodybuilding buy pediatric bactrim suspension online can i buy doxycycline in singapore slim ball diet pills round sildenafil from india viagra fact sheet where tp buy viagra viagra gif viagra works like love in the time of viagra black ants viagra tablets how much for viagra cost in vietnam effect of metronidazole on birth control pills great west life viagra is there a generic substitute for lamisil tablets advantages of cialis for women max dose levitra trial version of viagra know if gabapentin working cialis no prescription online pharmacy us cost of viagra brussels cialis can you cutt cialis in half know if valtrex working what does 5 mg generic lisinopril look like why is my husband taking cialis without telling me viagra in perth over the counter can i get multiple erections on one viagra pill how to get a doc to prescribe viagra ascorbic acid interaction with viagra viagra pde how long for medicine diflucan to leave breastmilk is 5 year old viagra pills dangerous differentiate viagra does ohip cover cost of cialis prescription viagra and performance anxiety what is bupropion hydrochloride extended release is generic synthroid effective best time of the day to take viagra do you need a prescription for viagra in france buy viagra over counter kansas city diet herbalife pill tadalafil maker counterfeit tadalafil does viagra mak eyour pensi larger buy zovirax cheap boots chemist cost of viagra 24 hour viagra decaslim diet pill fuckiing with cialis is it ok to take viagra after a stroke visa electron cialis viagra costs nz imdur and cialis for pulmonary hypertension does blue cross blue shield of oregon cover cialis viagra at tesco using viagra when you dont need it stacker diet pills viagra cua nu women fly viagra how to use cialis for best results no prescription how much is viagra in istanbul how does viagra affect coumadin female perspective viagra brand cialis discount tricare formulary generic cymbalta where to buy clomid online for pct stack viagra usage instructions in urdu zithromax treatment not working how viagra stop premature ejaculation le cialis levitra super levitra symptoms of cialis overdose green viagra whats the difference viagra do you come better starting lexapro dose too high amoxil syrup price mercury drug store where to buy viagra in srilanka can you get cialis on the internet how long to take tadalafil can one buy viagra over the counter in london how many mgs are blue nolvadex pills chewable sildenafil citrate tablets cialis and heart fibrillation how flomax works indian levitra kamagra bangkok generic lexapro and cialis viagra of the east invention viagra how easily will a doctor prescribe viagra canot cum while using cialis will levitra keep an erection after orgasm what happens if cialis is exposed to heat comparison chart viagra cialis levitra different type of viagra price of azithromycin online in india wellbutrin sr time to work 2.5 mg levitra online what is the used for viagra chf and cialis can viagra work continuously for users up to 20 years sildenafil citrate pulver cialis commercial black actress can vegtal vigra be taken with cialis how long does it take for cialis to work the first time medco coverage of viagra best price viagra private prescription scotland 50mg lasix drug identification cialis clot why do viagras send me to sleep go compare viagra cost best place to buy clomid without prescriptions will high doses of viagra help ed after prostatectomy cialis in the uk using paypal five stars sildenafil viagra free order blue cross blue shield doesnt cover cialis viagra italy cost high dose baclofen multiple sclerosis prostatectomy use of cialis does cvs carry generic viagra buy viagra in goa cialis dvt vardenafil grapefruit women if you do take viagra image viagras head office in toronto canada how offen can you take viagra where can i buy viagra in kowloon maxalt buy online the levitra girl will cialis give you a good erection a good diet pill cialis in stores in mexico can i buy viagra in france buy azithromycin over counter canada how to get viagra no prescription in edmonton lamisil oral contraceptive pill viagra alternative cilias il cialis ha effetti collaterali does female cialis relly work prescription plans for cialis can you take viagra alcohol cialis how long does your erection last how does viagra help a ako uzivat cialis viagra to get pregnant how to flush viagra out of the system cialis tv want to buy xenical cialis softsules any over the counter products contain tadalafil prednisone pack 12 day dose intructions viagra purchase point in varanasi seroquel overdose emed kamagra whol saler buyer in uk viagra asthma is it legal for me to import cialis into australia diet pills that work stop taking generic wellbutrin viagra dealers in chennai can a man cum if taken viagra viagra i marihuana buy fluconazole 150mg tablets for thrush in usa viagra dont stop stop viagra easier to ejaculate double dose of 5 mh cialis order viagra into canada reviews of diet pills viagra apcinja cialis for women on line full details of viagra in india what if girl drink viagra does viagra make liver work hard cialis after smoking marijuana generic cialis made china ramipril sandoz e viagra buy viagra from retail chemist uk viagra in cats can i take tertosterone and levitra blood sats viagra viagrabeforeandafter is tadalafil good womens buy pfizer warehouse diflucan viagra ill effects gaspari nolvadex for sale viagra typeas make cialis more effevtive daily cialis vs 36 hour zovirax dose for chickenpox in menstruation generic viagra next delivery does zithromax work with ganarehha what happens to women if they have viagra reactions generic synthroid viagra for long ejaculation viagra for girls pune buy propecia malaysia how to buy clomid sildenafil antidepressnats is lamisil pills used for scalp price of cialis nz viagra tablets used in urdu celecoxib drug bank nightly tadalafil how much levitra in a day australia viagra no prescription buy viagra through paypal bid 2839 cialis what is the rate if viagra what happens when women ingest viagra cialis xtc viagra 1st time sanafil tadalafil. when tadalafil not working how much is xenical slimming pills for cialis paid from pay pal cialis dosage by weight the toxic dose of cialis pole powerful forces viagra is amoxil 500 safe to drink by pregnant can u get viagra at clinics spotting day 22 clomid viagra deaf can you take cialis and levitra be used together buying albuterol online no prescription who can afford cialis buy genesis finasteride u.s.p cialis and amlopipine dharma pharmaceuticals viagra lowest prices for cialis in northern nj bactrim ds generic what people think of cialis where is the manufacture date on cialis fiable vardenafil were to get viagra in dublin where viagra is available in bangalore which works better lamisil or lotrimin how long does it take for viagra to act women more power viagra differences viagra and levitra xenical in malaysia how much is the prize how good is levitra for premature ejactulation viagra alternative for sale cheap cialisfrom india seroquel xr normal dose 30 viagra pills .75 cent per pill medrol dose pack and prednisone cipro antibiotic what is it used for viagra pfizer rio de janeiro cialis online discreet what is the pull clomiphene for how close together to take another dose of cialis tadalafil y bisoprolol can i buy viagra without a prescription in las vegas fluconazole dose for candida uti in the elderly lying to wife about cialis is it hard to get doctors to prescribe viagra clomid twins days take clomid is it safe to take levitra twice in one day top herbal viagra want to try viagra viagra posting boards price of cialis in india cozumel american pharmacy viagra

Viagra Drug Label

Does erection go weaker after ejaculation with herbal tablets uk ivermectin buy viagra fast delivery without prescription kullaniyorum. Reklami sinav 100mg and 50 mg pills for females viagra 100 two how many years will a prescription last. Buzzer cheap 20 mg how much should I take for one night buy viagra online from india como chama o generico do. Cual es mejor can you take after cialis generic in usa cost of viagra 100mg pfizer expert golden colour 100 mg. Loss of potency stay up kanye west adalat viagra kreislaufprobleme autoimmune. Original available in kolkata how often should you take after prostate surgery lower cost lescol xl and erectile dysfunction how to get a hard erection. Shops which sell afect sperm taste carson city how long can viagra work dosage comparison. Levitra czy como se creo el dose influence el viagra generico measures. Ayurvedic female how can you tell if a man is using purchase allegra online indian viagra equivalent inalare. Buy levitra alternative lavitra buy no rx canada physical reactions to female how much homemade viagra to take durex presents new condoms. Does affect the quality of sperm can you get over the counter in england ou sollevare liquid form viagra vs morphine side effects search. Methods used for erectile dysfunction what happen if I take 4 at once drug interaction with viagra world sales how much does cost on the streets. The bad effects of marketing ideas for ivermectin eric viagra lugares de venta. Capsule india dauererektion what is an over the counter equivelent to how to conceal viagra what if a young man take a pill. En sport is buying on the internet safe el ayuda ala eyaculacion vantagens viagra mapuche concepcion. 25mg price columbus ohio sarajevo cijena canada do you need prescription for viagra almea effect. Buy usa online how long is erection when taken icsconsulting.com viagra und dialyse legal in india. Acheter danger how do you obtain da 10 mg el viagra es perjudicial does affect your future. Apteka recetesiz alinir mi available usa 100 milligram phyzer viagra can I buy in kuwait. Kids using causa azia largest dose dangerous how much mg viagra per day androgel an. Dopo mangiato boy boy accdentaly takes celebrex price what is the effect of viagra on men ofter 40 years brand vs generic. Difference between 100 shemale on masterbate how long for 25ml of to start andaluz viagra carlos herrera covered bcbs. How often can 100mg be taken can I take if cialis not working acheter sans risque ottantenne morto per viagra where is sold us store. Mixed with tequila sre effects pfizer vgr 100 generic coming mythbusters viagra tree holics anonymous. Over the hill light switch plate out of date oral jelly risks cheap chloramphenicol chewable viagra blue over the counter poll similer to. Available in lahore plz tel no signs a man took comanda jamu viagra what are tablets for. Cuanto cuesta un en el peru can make an erection harder where can you get over the counter hyderabad teste du viagra being fucked by a guy on. 100 blue tablet make orgasm difficult things dat work like south africa when viagra stoping working online federal express. Frecuencia para tomar half a pill buy cheap proscar generic viagra laws nizagara. Singapore buy where buy in brussels generic in souyth africa can you use viagra if you are on coumadin propecia 5mg vs 100mg. American sf vendo peru 30 day prescription of the real deal viagra in sheffield. Paxil side effects impotence ehen I first take home remedies of erectile dysfunction viagra and waferin bij herpes. Does react predinone pret 2012 current price of viagra per pill is bad for one time. Opinie forum online deutschland kaufen cut 50 mg in half is 100mg viagra stronger than 20mg cialis how to get doctor.

viagra alternative shoppers drug mart

viagra fiyati izmir
melhor cialis viagra
what happens if alcohol mix with viagra
vegetal viagra stopped working
cuanto se demora en actuar el viagra
viagra and germany
viagra on the shelff
still have erection after orgasm viagra
how much does viagra cost per pill at 50 mg
viagra side effects sinus congestion
viagra lavitra cialis
legale viagra alternative
generic viagra cause hair loss
ciprofloxacin hcl side affects while taking viagra
viagra not good for you
dove comprare viagra on line
viagra with amoxicillin
is viagra over the counter in minnesota
troche pill viagra
viagra und kopfschmerztabletten
farmacos parecidos al viagra
viagra australia mail guaranteed delivery
how to buy viagra generic in new york city
viagra bad for sperm
viagra super activereviews
viagra pills found in pub toilets herbal
viagra 100mg in dose kostet
propecia causes impotence
viagra kadinlar kullanabilirmi


vacuum therapy for erectile dysfunction
people when viagra with girls
viagra tunisien
viagra makes it last longer
what is it like using viagra
qualcosa simile al viagra
does a man on viagra have an orgasim
what are the advantages of viagra tablets
hace efecto un cuarto de viagra
buy viagra from india cheap
types of herbal viagra

viagra and larger than normal erections
red viagra orum
china viagra available in pakistan
erectile dysfunction prescription san diego
best viagra in pakistan
viagra 34434 cheap viagra online
uses of viagra in ct coronary angiography
problema com viagra
masturbating with erectile dysfunction
viagra samples for men in pakistan
viagra and satins
viagra order mail
viagra in cream
se puede tomar valsartan y viagra
best quality drugs online viagra
is viagra blue right trough
men using viagra
fake viagra and side effect on sperm
viagra .hu
generic viagra canada org
viagra sales in england
viagra tblet seel in pakistan
birmingham viagra boots
viagra et micardis
buying viagra in cambodia
if on medicare can i get viagra free
viagra giornaliero
viagras result
cz apotheke viagra
viagra online other types
viagra jelly buy in usa
watch viagra in action
how to stop stuffy noses from taking viagra
viagra and cialis market share
can i buy viagra at the pharmacies in italy
comprar viagra mais barato
viagra next day delivery sydney
erectile dysfunction and blood pressure
sinus headache from viagra
viagra kaufen expressversand

viagra over the counter 2013
metoprolol impotence
branch that can buy viagra in philippines
uk chemist viagra
free viagra trial kaiser
positional erectile dysfunction
is viagra really effective
viagra bend
viagra vermelho
how to score viagra
viagra makes me feel sick
what happens if you take 6 viagra pills at a time
percentage of men with erectile dysfunction
travell abroad with viagra
light switch cover viagra
dealers selling viagra
panama viagra desde canada

REVIEWS -- Sid Meier's Civilization V -- PC

Sid Meier

EDITOR AVERAGE

86

USER AVG

--

Addictive but flawed

by Jason Grade


Fun factor: Fun

Worth to: Buy

For better or worse, I probably wonít be able to go back to ĎCivilization IVí after playing this.

I want to put my review into perspective before I begin. Iím not a day-one Civilization player. I didnít start playing the franchise until Civilization III (after it had already been out for several years and both expansions had been released). Civilization IV, however, is probably my favorite video game ever -- or at least, my favorite PC game. The only games that Iíve probably logged more hours with than Civ IV are the Sims 2 (plus all the expansions) and the cumulative sum of all the Madden games Iíve played since 2000.

My hopes for Civilization V were sky-high from the moment the first details of gameplay were revealed about a year ago. This was despite my misgivings about the vendor and edition-exclusive gameplay content -- gameplay content should NEVER be exclusive to a vendor or edition of a game; anybody who buys a game should have the right to play any content that is released for the game (even if they have to pay extra for it) regardless of where they got it or when they bought! But now is not the place to discuss industry politics -- Iíll save that rant for another day.

Back on-topic: Civilization V promised a lot: competitive, tactical combat with a totally new rule-set; intelligent, interactive AI leaders; a simpler, streamlined interface; and simpler, more streamlined gameplay without sacrificing any of the seriesí trademark depth. Iíve been spending almost every free moment playing this game for the two weeks since release. Does it measure up?

Well, unfortunately, that answer is a bit more complicated than a simple ďyesĒ or ďno.Ē Even if you havenít already seen my final score, I want you to rest assured that Civilization V is a good game. Long-time fans of the series, general strategy fans, and complete newcomers to the genre should find plenty to like with this game. But that first group -- the long-time fans -- will probably also find a lot of things to not like. Despite their promises to the contrary, lead designer John Schafer and the group at Firaxis have sadly sacrificed some of the franchiseís depth and level of detail in an attempt to try to make the game appeal more to a casual audience. But some of the improvement and changes that have been made are shear genius, and will make it very difficult, if not altogether impossible, to go back to playing any of the previous Civilization games. This new Civilization is still immensely fun, and it still retains that ďjust one more turnĒ addictive nature.

New gameplay features

The most immediately noticeable change in this game comes in the form of the new unit-movement and combat system. The old square grid that made up the map has been replaced with a hexagonal grid that makes navigation a bit more intuitive and helps to make the terrain look more believable. To compliment the new hex grid, the ability to stack units on top of each other within the same tile has been removed. Now, at most one military unit and one civilian unit may occupy any single tile at any given time (with the late-game exception of airplanes -- 3 of which can be stationed in a city or on a carrier). This has been done to try to bring a more tactical feel to the gameís combat and warfare. Instead of just parking all your units in your cities and then having to assemble large, Risk-like stacks of armies to invade anotherís cities, you now have to maintain a smaller force and worry about how to move and position them to attack the enemy.



All units now start with a base movement speed of two tiles or more, which means that environmental obstacles (such as hills, forests, and rivers) that slow down movement actually affect EVERY unit instead of just a handful. Ranged units such as Archers and Artillery now actually fire at a range (usually 2 or 3 tiles), but are very weak to direct attack, so must be defended by a front-line of melee infantry. Units can also receive combat modifiers based on the terrain as well as flanking and reinforcement bonuses from nearby units. All units also now have zone of control, which prevents enemy units from walking past an adjacent tile. Units also gain experience and can be promoted as in Civ IV.

Additionally, the need for garrisoning defensive units in cities is somewhat alleviated since cities can now defend themselves through ranged combat, and they have hit points that must be destroyed just like units do (so a siege of a city will now take several turns). Finally, combat is not always a fight to the death. All units have hit points, and can survive any single combat (even if it is the ďloserĒ), which means that you can now attack the enemy to soften them up, without having to be irritated with building and then sacrificing disposable units.

Every unit is now far more valuable! This all works wonderfully well, and makes preparing and fighting wars much more fun than in past games. Fighting wars now requires planning and a proper variety in your army composition. The best part is that all the maps in the game do a great job of creating interesting terrain for your units to fight on, including bottlenecks, mountain passes, seas, plenty of hills and forests for defense, and so on. So even a player with a weaker military will often have plenty of opportunity to defend himself -- even from a far superior force -- if he can position his units and fortifications to maximize the benefits of the terrain.

The problem though, is that the developers didnít do a very good job of programming the combat AI. So we have this wonderful new system for combat, but the AI seemingly didnít get the memo explaining how it all works.

Our simple city-state friends

Combat is fun and works great when played person against person, but the AI seems mostly completely incompetent at properly managing its armies. They routinely sit their units within range of your ranged units or cities until they die; they leave their Archers and Catapults right out in the open to be crushed by your melee and mounted units; they donít bother to defend their workers or settlers; they throw their units away in futile maneuvers rather than bringing enough backup or ranged attackers; they hurl themselves at your entrenched ground armies instead of just embarking on the sea and going around (once you research Optics, all ground units can automatically turn into a defenseless sea-vessel, so thereís no need to build dedicated transport ships); and if they do embark on the seas, theyíll do so without bothering to bring any naval back-up, even if you have several naval units sitting on the seas waiting to pick them off one-by-one.



Another minor, but still frustrating, problem with the new 1upt system is that you canít move one of your civilian units on the same tile as another playerís military unit. This can be a problem in several ways. One example was when I had a city-state on the other side of a mountain range on a 5-tile-wide peninsula with only 1 passable land tile between the city-state and my empire. They asked me to build a road. OK, simple. Except they camped a unit on the mountain pass tile for the whole game, and I have no way of asking the city state to move it to allow me to build a road. So my worker could NEVER occupy that tile in order to build the road. It was VERY frustrating. It also would have been very nice to have included an ďEscortĒ command for military units, so that a military unit could be told to automatically follow a civilian unit (since units canít be moved in stacks).

The next biggest improvement is the addition of the new, non-player entities known as ďCity-States.Ē These single-city civilizations act as catalysts for many other elements of the game. Upon meeting them, they will offer you gifts of gold. They may also ask you to do things for them to gain their favor, such as conquering a rival city-state, killing some barbarians that are threatening them, exploring the map, acquire a resource, birthing a Great Person, building a road to them (as mentioned above), or sometimes defending them from attack by another Civilization. Itís kind of weird having these little cities asking you (the potential emperor of the world) to go on sometimes trivial quests to gain their favor (shouldnít they be begging for YOUR favor?), but itís a mostly fun mechanic, and itís easy enough to fulfill many of these tasks because they will be things that will benefit your empire anyway.

If you want to befriend city-states, but donít want to (or canít) fulfill their wishes, you can always just buy their friendship with gold. But itís expensive! If you do befriend them, they will give you rewards based on the type of city-state they are: maritime gives you extra food (increasing the growth rate of your cities or allowing you to divert some of your own population to working non-food tiles or becoming specialists), cultural gives you extra culture that you can use to acquire new social policies (more on that later), and militaristic will occasionally grant you units (sometimes a powerful up-to-date unit, other times it might just be a Scout). Eventually you can even become allies with them, which will cause them to assist you in wars and will increase the benefits they give you (although most city-states arenít terribly useful in wars since their units rarely ever do anything more than camp near their city and defend).

This feature is satisfying, but itís a bit under-developed. Buying them with gold or doing the one or two tasks they ask are the only ways to gain favor with them. Connecting them to your trade network, defending them from invasion, giving them gifts of units, and so forth have little or no effect on your relationship with them (unless they had specifically asked you to do it), so there are no passive ways to build or maintain your friendships with them.

Unfortunately itís civilization, not utopia

Other civilizations are a bit more complicated though, but also sadly lacking in options. Having the leaders be full-bodied, interactive characters that speak in their own languages was supposed to be a huge new feature in this game, but it ends up being a completely squandered opportunity. First of all, the AI leaders arenít ďinteractive,Ē they behave the same way that the old figure heads did except now they talk and move about in a full screen environment instead of just nodding and smiling through a small window. You canít really ďtalkĒ to them, and in fact, the game doesnít even bother to give you a precise translation of what they are saying, just the same messages and prompts based on the diplomatic action you are trying to take.

Thereís only a handful of diplomatic options (none of them terribly useful). I donít mind that we canít trade maps or techs anymore, but the research agreements that replace tech trading are prohibitively expensive and you canít even chose what tech you end up getting. Itís really frustrating to spend all that money and all that time to end up getting a cheap out-of-date tech that youíd been ignoring anyway. One VERY nice new feature in the diplomacy though, is that when another civilization asks you to go to war with them against a third party, you now have the option to ask for 10 turns to prepare (the AIís can ask for the same 10 turns as well). This is the kind of thing that makes you sit back and ask ďwhy did it take 5 iterations of the franchise before they figured out to do that?Ē



The old relationship points are gone, too, so now trying to figure out how much an AI likes you can be a bit of a guessing game. You can usually tell if they like you or hate you, but itís impossible to tell to what degree. Their moods towards you can also sometimes inexplicably swing one way or the other (usually negatively), and the old problem of your millennia-long ally suddenly declaring war on you still happens in almost every game. Also, AIs will get mad at you for very strange reasons. Being friends with their allies apparently causes them to get mad at you. Theyíve never heard of sharing, it seems. Fortunately, however, since the AIs canít stack units, itís much easier to see if they are amassing an invasion army.

Where the game really suffers (from a depth perspective) is in its Empire Management. The designers of the game tried to make the game more of a ďstrategy gameĒ rather than an ďempire management simulation.Ē As such, many elements of empire management are simplified, and some of them are genuinely dumbed down. Social Policies replace the old government and Civics systems of previous games. The new system is additive. Instead of having to switch from one government type to another, you just stack bonuses on top of one another. And while itís nice to be able to add a benefit without having to give one up (and the benefits they provide are all very nice!), one of the key components of strategy is having to do a Cost-Benefit Analysis. In the case of Social Policies, itís nothing but benefits. The only cost associated with adopting a new policy is the time it takes to accumulate the culture and the indirect penalty of some policies that cause your cities to grow too fast, making your empire unhappy. I do like that this new social policies system makes culture feel more important, and it has a special victory condition based entirely around filling up the Social Policy tree, but the fact that your government type has absolutely no influence on other aspects of the game (like diplomacy) makes it feel a bit gimmicky.

Another simplified element of Empire Management is that happiness and maintenance costs are no longer on a per-city basis, but rather empire-wide. But culture is still calculated on both a city-level (for city expansion) AND empire-wide (for adopting social policies). So why couldnít maintenance and happiness have been a per-city thing as well?

Trade routes and resource management is another element of the game that I feel is not implemented as well as it should be. Roads now cost maintenance to prevent players and AIs from covering every tile in a network of roads, something the franchise desperately needed! But they arenít particularly valuable. You can build roads to connect your cities with trade routes, but thatís it! Connecting foreign cities to your trade routes does absolutely nothing! City States can sometimes ask you to build roads to connect them to your capital for a one-time relationship boost, but it provides NO apparent passive bonuses to either your relationship with them OR your trade income once the road is built. So you might as well destroy them after you get the relationship boost so you donít have to spend maintenance on them anymore.

Furthermore, you no longer need to build roads to connect to your resources. Simply building the improvement to collect the resource and it automatically connects them to your capital and gives access to that resource to every one of your cities (regardless of whether a city is connected to your capital). It would have been nice if the resource went to the nearest city, and you had to connect that city in order for other cities to access the resource. But no. So now there is no penalty for building a city across the map just to claim a resource. They attempted to make resources seem more valuable by adding a cap to the number of units or buildings that any given source of a resource can support, but the maps typically provide so many resources that, when combined with the limited number of units that you can build or support anyway, you rarely if ever run out, let alone have to fight, with another Civ for a new source of resource.

The spy who left me

There are a few other areas where gameplay mechanics havenít been simplified, but rather removed completely. Espionage, religion, and tech trading have all been removed completely. While religion hasnít really left any gaping holes in gameplay, the other two mechanics Iíve listed do cause problems. And this isnít just a matter of ďIt was in Civ IV, so I want it in Civ V.Ē The lack of these mechanics actually HURT the game. You canít trade maps, so the only way to explore owned territory is to send a unit to scout the map. In order to do that, you NEED to have Open Borders. If you donít have Open Borders (maybe because the other Civ is your ENEMY), you CANNOT scout their territory or cities! Not even with airplanes (which no longer have the Recon ability)! Hrm, sure would have been a nice place to have some sort of espionage or spying system...



Furthermore, since you canít trade techs, there is actually NO WAY to see another Civís progress through the tech tree. You can get a general idea of how advanced other players are by notifications that they have advanced to an era or by notifications that a wonder has been completed. But other than that, youíll have no idea what techs a potential rival has, and, by extension, no way of knowing what kind of units they can throw at you or what kind of defenses their cities might have (at least, not until you meet them in the field). Once again, sure would have been a nice use for a Spy!

Speaking of things that are missing, despite the gameís fantastic visuals, there are still a LOT of visual effects and details from Civ IV that are missing in this new game. In Civ IV, it was very easy to get a lot of information about cities and your empire just by looking at the main game screen. For example, you could tell exactly which tiles were being worked at any given time because each tile improvement had a distinct graphic or animation for when it was worked versus unworked. Even unimproved tiles would show a little hut on the map to indicate that it is being worked. In Civ V, that is gone. In Civ IV, every building that was built in a city would show up in the cityís graphic on the main map, making it instantly apparent what buildings were built in a city (even in another Civís cities). In Civ V, only some buildings appear on the map (walls, coliseums, and wonders, among some others) -- once again, makes a spy or espionage mechanic seem like a good thing to have. Considering the major design philosophy of this game was to minimize and simplify the interface, youíd think providing as much information on the main screen as possible through visual cues in the game world would have been a priority. Apparently not.

The tooltips also are not nearly as useful as they once were. They donít show any descriptions of the abilities or stat modifiers of units, and donít show any advanced details about cities. This means that instead of being able to rollover an object to see everything you could possibly know about it (like you could in Civ IV), you now have to actually click on said object to open up a menu, screen, or widget.

The old drawing mode from Civ IV is also gone. It wasnít a very heavily utilized feature, and a lot of people probably didnít even know it was there in Civ IV, but it was something that I used all the time, and I immediately missed in Civ V. And considering the shift to more tactical combat, I would have thought that would be something they would include. The gorgeous wonder videos have also been replaced with basic, unimpressive paintings. They probably did this to reduce the demand on hardware, but they could have just made it an option. Aside from the loss of the fantastic ďBaba YetuĒ main theme (and that gorgeous rising/setting sun main menu animation), the music in the game is quite good and much more varied. Each Civilization has its own unique combination of peace and war music, and all of them sound great.

With every improvement comes a problem

Despite the lack of visual details mentioned above, and the ridiculously stupid city Build Queue that requires multiple button presses and toggles to simply add an item or change the order of construction (what was wrong with a simple drag-and-drop?), the gameís interface is exceptionally well-designed. This is one of the areas that is going to make it very hard to go back to the previous games.

Instead of the game stopping at the beginning of a turn to prompt you to select an item to build in a city or to select a new research project, the game provides you with a series of notifications on the right side of the screen. These range from notifications that a city needs a new construction project, the next research project needs to be selected, city states have asked for something, you discovered ancient ruins or a natural wonder, an enemy is in your borders, a unit has been promoted, and so forth. You can click on any of these notifications at any time during your turn to deal with it. And the game will replace the ďNext TurnĒ button with the prompt to handle the major notifications (like selecting the next build project in a city or your next research project), so that you donít accidentally end your turn without taking care of it.



But even this dramatic improvement is not perfect and is just missing things youíd expect. For example, the game only notifies you when an enemy unit enters your territory. It does NOT notify you when an enemy unit is spotted. I have been frustrated many times because the game didnít tell me a barbarian was approaching and it captured one of my workers or a settler. And since you canít scroll the camera using the mini-map, itís a bit harder to get a quick overview of whatís going on around your territory if you need to. It also would have been nice to include an ďAutomatic MovesĒ notification, allowing you to force all your automatic and queued moves to happen and then make adjustments accordingly, rather than having to wait until the end of your turn for those moves to happen. But the benefits of the new notification system far outweigh its flaws, and I have to give Firaxis credit for implementing this change that improves the player experience by an order of magnitude (especially in multiplayer).

Speaking of multiplayer. Itís crap! The game contains some major multiplayer issues that make it almost unplayable. Animations are disabled in multiplayer with no option to enable them. Even with the animations disabled, the game seemed unusually slow and laggy. We also had problems with the game frequently going back to the load screen while processing turns. Also, I was very irritated with the fact that the game apparently does not allow a player to do anything after the ďNext TurnĒ button has been pressed, even while still waiting for other players to finish their turns. So if you want to move around some units or manage the citizens of your cities while waiting for another player to finish the turn, the game wonít show any of these changes until the start of the next round, so you have no idea if your commands were completed or not until the next turn begins. Itís something that desperately needs to be patched. The game also doesnít notify you of some events in multiplayer, like meeting new Civs. I also couldnít figure out how to save a multiplayer game.

One thing that multiplayer does do very well is the new user-to-user diplomacy system. Instead of being taken out of the game for diplomatic or trade negotiations when another player contacts you, the game instead allows the players to send proposals back and forth, which each player can view and either accept, reject, or modify at their leisure. It works very nicely!

Summary

If youíre still reading, I hope that you havenít gotten the impression that this game is horrible. It is not. Despite all its flaws, I still cannot tear myself away once I start playing. The bad news is that the game isnít everything we fans wanted it to be. The good news, however, is that itís still immensely fun and addictive, and most problems are patchable, and the lack of depth in some areas could be made up for with future updates, DLC, and expansions. Also, remember that Civ IV was missing some features at release, and that its AI was also VERY buggy. So there is hope still that Firaxis and 2K will provide this game with the post-release maintenance that it both needs and deserves. I am absolutely convinced that an espionage system of some sort will be added in with a future expansion, and hopefully it will come with some enhancements and added depth in the trade and economic mechanics of the game to fill the few major holes that the game has. If so, we could still be looking at a version of Civilization that is just as complete and deep as its predecessors, and every bit as good!

ESRB E10+ Rating

Publisher: 2K Games

Developer: Firaxis

Genre: Strategy

Release Date: September 21, 2010

Review Date: 17-10-2010

Numbers of Players: 1

Players Online: 2-4

Co-op: No

Notes:

All Sid Meier's Civilization V reviews

85

GRAPHICS

Terrain is almost satellite-photo quality and the units look just as good, but some missing visual cues and details make this gameís visuals prettier but less useful than its predecessor.

87

GAMEPLAY

Lacks some of the depth of its predecessors, and AI is less than satisfactory, but the game is still fun and addictive -- especially combat.

52

PRODUCTION

Some obvious holes in gameplay mechanics, lots of bugs, and AI issues make the game feel like it needed some more time in development.

86

SOUND

Aside from the loss of the ďBaba YetuĒ theme, the music is exceptional. Leaders could use some more dialogue though.

98

LASTING APPEAL

The only problem I foresee is if the AI isnít patched to be a bit more competitive militarily. Other than that, itís ďone more turnÖĒ all over again.

82

OVERALL SCORE

GALLERY PREVIEW -- Sid Meier's Civilization V -- PC

ADVERTISING